Showing posts with label Opticos Design. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Opticos Design. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 23, 2015

Missing Middle Housing Hiding in Plain Sight


Earlier this year, I wrote about missing middle housing, a term coined by Opticos Design of Berkeley to describe housing that is neither conventional single-family homes nor multi-story apartments, but fills the gap between those two with duplexes, granny flats, and their like.  Well-executed missing middle housing, meaning housing that is compatible with the overall feel of a neighborhood, can be crucial to a community because it adds more people to the street while also widening the housing costs options, expanding the demographic breadth of neighborhoods.

The earlier post gathered significant readership.  But I didn’t need the readers’ opinions to know that missing middle housing was an important element of urbanism.  I was already looking with new eyes at my neighborhood, spotting missing middle housing where it had previously eluded me.

So, on this day with Christmas nearly upon us and the heavy lifting of urbanist philosophy too much for my light-hanging, gift-wrapping, meal-preparing fatigue, I’ll take a neighborhood tour, sharing some of my favorites. 

But before beginning the tour, I should explain how several aspects of my neighborhood make it particularly well-prepared for missing middle housing.

To begin, it’s an older neighborhood, with many homes going back a century or more.  Whereas modern subdivisions line up in military fashion, conforming closely to minimum setbacks and giving dictatorial oversight to homeowners’ associations, leaving little opportunity for later generations to adlib, older neighborhoods are filled with often quirky one-off homes that offer room for creativity.

Next, the neighborhood originally had a strong agricultural slant, so many back yards were deep enough to allow egg production, the mainstay of the Petaluma economy a century ago.  The deep lots now give opportunities for missing middle housing.

Also, the agricultural focus of a century ago created a need for more modest worker housing, broadening the range of existing homes and making missing middle housing an easier fit.

Also, agricultural neighborhoods tend to have streets that are more radial, originally aligned to provide efficient market access from the early farmsteads.  Radial streets, when subdivided into rectilinear lots, have odd leftover spaces that can provide settings for middle housing creativity.

Lastly, the City of Petaluma, recognizing the already strong neighborhood culture of supplemental housing units and not choosing to make those units “grandfathered non-conforming uses”, applied zoning to the neighborhood that allows many types of supplemental housing.  There can still be institutional barriers to missing middle housing, starting with impact fees, but zoning isn’t one of them.

With the background established, let’s take a tour.

Just a few doors from our home is what seems to be tidy little single-family home on a corner.  But it’s not.  Around the corner is a second home, of a completely different architectural style, occupying the same lot.  The two homes sharing a lot, each with a tiny backyard and separate garage, creates a second home out of thin air.

Three short blocks away, and shown above, is what appears at first glance to be a single-family house consistent with the neighborhood.  But a second glance, and a careful count, shows three front doors.  It’s a triplex, with three modest units, almost exactly a half-mile from the center of downtown, so within the range of walkability.

Even closer to downtown is a home that was neglected for years.  With the exterior sagging, windows broken, and weeds poised for a final offensive, I thought the next step would be demolition.  But the bones were apparently strong.  A major rehab brought the house back to life as a duplex with doors facing both streets.

Last is a home that I know well.  When my cousins bought the property, there were only the homes at the front and rear.  They then built, with the tiniest bit of assistance from me, a garage/office between the first two homes.  The new structure isn’t a residence, but with only a few modifications and the payment of impact fees, it could be.  Three tidy homes on a single lot.  If that became the norm, middle housing wouldn’t be missing anymore.

This isn’t meant as a comprehensive survey of missing middle housing in my neighborhood.  There are more missing middle homes that I can still share.  But this is a reasonable introduction for a holiday week.  And perhaps an inducement for readers to begin looking about their own neighborhoods to see if the need for missing middle housing is being met or needs encouragement.

My next post will fall on Christmas Day.  I’ll write of a gift that I hope to give myself on Christmas Eve.

As always, your questions or comments will be appreciated.  Please comment below or email me.  And thanks for reading. - Dave Alden (davealden53@comcast.net)

Wednesday, April 22, 2015

Missing Middle Housing: Where to Find It and Where to Encourage It

I’ve written about Opticos Design of Berkeley and one of its principals, Dan Parolek, on several earlier occasions.  First, I reported on Opticos’ role as the lead consultant for the Petaluma Station Area Plan.  More recently, I noted the national award given to Opticos by the Congress for the New Urbanism for their work with Cincinnati’s new form-based code.

And now, I can report that Opticos has begun staking out a key element of urbanism as their particular domain.  In Parolek’s term, it’s the “missing middle housing”.

I recommend reading Parolek’s entire article on missing middle housing.  It runs long, but Parolek uses his words well, explaining the urban gaps left behind by the missing middle housing and some possible configurations for reestablishing it.  But for those without the extra minutes, I’ll try to summarize.

Most use-based zoning codes divide residential uses into single-family and multi-family.  Within the two categories, there is usually a variation in allowable densities, but ultimately there is a clear physical delineation between single-family and multi-family homes.

If we look around neighborhoods that have been built since World War II, the line is obvious.  Multi-family housing is almost always a place apart, built by different developers, served by different parking, and separated from single-family homes by clearly evident fencing or landscape buffers.

But if we look at older city neighborhoods, the places that were developed before the use-based zoning codes assumed their dominance, we find a blurring of the line.  Stealthily scattered among the single-family homes are buildings that have a scale and character similar to single-family homes, but contain multiple residences.  Those buildings are important to city life because they provide the density necessary to support walkability without undermining the single-family feel that many find comfortable.

But with many recent zoning codes having outlawed these middle housing options, hence Parolek’s use of “missing”, the potential for walkability is undermined.  Parolek argues that reestablishing the missing middle is a key step toward reestablishing walkability.

Parolek goes on to present possible configurations for new neighborhoods with the missing middle restored.

With Parolek’s words fresh in my mind, I relooked at some older neighborhoods of Petaluma, visiting examples of the missing middle about which he wrote.  And then I considered the future of a neighborhood that will soon come under pressure to change, perhaps adding more of the missing middle.

Interestingly enough, my visit to examples of the missing middle began before I even left my driveway.  Directly across the street are three small buildings that may have begun life as a motel.  (In the days of slower transportation, Petaluma would have been a logical place to spend a night before continuing onward to the Sonoma County coast.)  Or it’s possible that the buildings originally housed workers in the egg industry that once dominated my part of town.

Today, the buildings contain six small apartments, tucked in a neighborhood that is otherwise solidly single-family.

And despite the concerns of some about bringing the missing middle into single-family neighborhoods (take a look at the third comment on the Parolek article), the folks who live in the apartments have blended well into our neighborhood.  We haven’t all become friends, but my wife and I have become sufficiently acquainted with several of the residents to invite them to our home for the annual neighborhood Christmas Eve party.  We’ve become even more familiar with their pets.

Moving further afield, I’ve always been charmed by tiny A Street.  Barely 300 feet in length, A Street is host to a collection of smaller single-family homes and larger, older homes that have been converted to apartments and a few offices.  Separated from downtown by only a parking lot, A Street provides a fine environment for those willing to leave their cars at the curb for the day.  It would be a different place if the larger homes hadn’t been subdivided to provide more density.

On the north edge of downtown, I’ve long been intrigued by a pair of Italianate apartment houses near the corner of Bodega Avenue and Howard Street.  The buildings appear to have been originally constructed as apartments, but scaled to fit within a neighborhood that is otherwise single-family, a cheek-to-jowl configuration that would rarely be permitted under contemporary zoning codes.

I finished my loop of Petaluma with the East D Street neighborhood.  Originally laid out as the far eastern extent of Petaluma, with large lots for extended produce gardens and poultry sheds, the neighborhood has long been encircled by the town.  Recognizing the potential income in additional dwelling units, much of the neighborhood has evolved to fill the oversized lots with Hollywood bungalows, granny flats, and an infill apartment house or two.

I’m pleased that East D Street has already begun an evolution toward filling the missing middle housing, but I suspect it will be under pressure to evolve even further.  The SMART station is slated to open in the next 18 months at the western edge of the neighborhood.  Hopefully not much later after that, development will start on the first elements of the Station Area Plan, with moderately dense residential extending outward from the station.  And perhaps a decade after that, the reuse of the current Fairgrounds may begin on the eastern flank of the neighborhood.

I applaud all of these changes, but I’ll also acknowledge that the changes will put pressure on the East D Street neighborhood to add further residents.  People will be attracted to the urban vitality and the easy transit access of the new developments, but some won’t be able to afford the cost to live in new construction.  Converting existing homes to apartments or adding granny flats within the East D Street neighborhood would be a solution toward which the market will push.

(As one example, two participants in the Urban Chat Fairgrounds process are looking for a site to try a creative approach to senior living.  I encourage their thinking, but have suggested that they look to acquire existing buildings in the East D Street neighborhood rather than a new Fairgrounds building.  Using existing buildings would control their capital costs.)

A well-written zoning code, preferably form-based, would help ensure that the East D Street neighborhood changes in a way that benefits both the existing and new residents.  I know that many residents of East D Street are happy with their neighborhood as it is, but the Station Area and the Fairgrounds will put pressure on the neighborhood to change.  And it’d be better to manage the change than to try to put a bell jar over the neighborhood.

In passing, I’ll also mention parking.  At present, it isn’t clear how much parking will be available at the station or how well Petaluma Transit can serve the station.  With those conditions, it’s likely that parking will spill into the East D Street neighborhood.  I suspect that parking management will quickly become a hot topic.  Although different than the missing middle housing challenge, the two may be susceptible to a coordinated solution.

There is irony in this discussion of East D Street.  As Opticos was beginning their work on the Station Area Plan, I suggested, in my role as a member of the Citizens Advisory Committee, that Opticos look at the East D Street neighborhood to help manage its transition.  They seemed amenable, but the look didn’t happen.  Perhaps there were funding or scoping issues of which I wasn’t aware.  But today, nearly five years later, Opticos is nationally recognized for their work on missing middle housing and the East D Street neighborhood is in need of a missing middle housing policy.  It was a missed opportunity.

The concept of missing middle housing is subtle, but real.  And it can be important to urban vitality.  If you’re motivated, take a look around your North Bay community and look for good examples of missing middle housing or places where missing middle housing could fill a need and then comment below, or email me, with your insights.  I’d like to see other North Bay communities through your eyes.

In my next post, I’ll return to the topic of more stringent water conservation standards.  The Petaluma City Council will be considering new rules at an upcoming meeting.  I won’t be able to attend, so will use this forum to add my final thoughts.  After listening to some of the community response at the earlier City Council meeting on the subject, I want to clarify my earlier comments.

As always, your questions or comments will be appreciated.  Please comment below or email me.  And thanks for reading. - Dave Alden (davealden53@comcast.net)

Friday, June 20, 2014

CNU 22: Bay Area Takes Top Awards

My last few posts have been about CNU 22, the 22nd annual meeting of the Congress for the New Urbanism, which was held earlier this month.  Today, I’ll turn to the Charter Awards, the recognition that CNU gives to the best urbanist efforts of the year.  

Among the strengths of CNU are the freedom to be flexible and the willingness of its members to take advantage of that flexibility.  Those strengths are appropriate to an organization leading the way in re-imagining a form of land use that was neglected for too long.

 The annual CNU Charter Awards are a fine example of the flexibility and self-initiative.  Each year, a Jury Chair is selected from among the more eminent members.  The Jury Chair is then given full discretion to pick the other members of his jury and even to realign the award categories if he wishes.

For the 2014 awards, the Jury Chair was Jeff Speck who wrote “Walkable City”, one of the most influential urbanist books of 2013.  For the 2014 awards, Speck took advantage of the CNU freedoms, appointing a distinguished panel, including Brent Toderian and Elizabeth Plater-Zyberk, both of whom have been mentioned often in this blog, and also redesignating many of the award categories to conform to his perspective on urbanism.

The San Francisco Bay Area thrived under the revised categories.  Faced with two strong projects between which they couldn’t decide, the jury awarded dual Grand Prizes.  Both winners had strong ties to the Bay Area.

The first project was Center Station, a newly-opened 157-unit affordable housing transit-oriented development (TOD) adjoining the Union City BART station.  In announcing the award, Speck noted that the project had everything, “TOD, affordability, great public spaces indoors and out, LEED Platinum, hidden parking, community gardens, social services, recreation, and public art, all wrapped up in a lively, contemporary package.”  Center Station was designed by David Baker Architects of San Francisco.

(I’ll be scheduling a BART trip to Union City to look at Center Station.  If anyone wishes to join me, let me know.  We can make it a field trip.)

The other Grand Prize winner was the newly adopted form-based code for Cincinnati, Ohio.  (For newer readers, a form-based code focuses on building shapes along a “transect” from rural settings to urban cores.  It’s an alternative to use-based codes which propagated after World War II and helped facilitate sprawl.)

In the aftermath of the post World War II suburban exodus, Cincinnati was left with a wealth of interesting but under-used buildings.  A zoning code was needed that would allow the city to re-establish itself effectively and efficiently as the demographic tides began moving back toward cities.  A form-based code met that need.

The planning firm that worked with Cincinnati was Opticos Design of Berkeley, considered among the leaders in form-based codes.  It was a return to the award platform for Opticos, who received a Charter Award in 2013 for their work on a Richmond planning project.

Opticos is also known in the North Bay, having been the consultant on the Station Area Master Plan that was adopted a year ago by the City of Petaluma.  (The writer served on the Citizens’ Advisory Committee for that planning effort, so had the opportunity to work with the outstanding Opticos staff.)

But the most interesting decision of the 2014 Charter Awards may have for Best Regional Plan.  The jury choose not to give an award this year, finding that the submitted entries were all either too idealistic to be implemented or too weak to have a meaningful impact.  Speck suggested that politics were to blame of the lack of meaningful regional plans, an observation that I suspect has much validity.

Not selecting an award winner was a bold decision to make.  If a CNU member submits a non-winning project in a category in which an award is made, he can reasonably convince himself that his project was fine, but had the ill fortune to bump into a better project.

But if the non-winning project is in a category for which the jury decides that none of the projects were worthy of an award, there is no rationalization.  The applicant is confronted with the reality that a jury of his fellow members judged that his project failed to meet the minimum standard for an award-worthy project.

I don’t know of any backlash against Speck or the jury for their decision.  But I respect the integrity that lay behind it.

Before Speck left the stage, he announced that Elizabeth Plater-Zyberk would be the Jury Chair for next year.  He expressed the hope that some of his innovations would remain in place, but with the acknowledgment that CNU tradition of flexibility would allow Plater-Zyberk to take the awards in any direction she wishes.  It was a sign of a progressive organization and mindset.

My next post will stay with CNU 22 one more time, examining some of the insights that were offered about the state of the planning profession.

As always, your questions or comments will be appreciated.  Please comment below or email me.  And thanks for reading. - Dave Alden (davealden53@comcast.net)