Showing posts with label Walkable City. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Walkable City. Show all posts

Friday, December 25, 2015

A Walkable Christmas Eve

I expect the youthful Christmas Eves of many readers were much like mine.

Sleep was usually slow in arriving.  Even as a six-year-old, I thought it ridiculous for our parents to expect my sister, cousins, and me to take naps so Santa Claus could make a 7pm visit to our grandparents’ house.

And wakefulness often arrived early.  I found no harm in a 3am foray to the Christmas tree for a preview of newly arrived stuff.

Even as the birthdays rolled past and Santa Claus receded in the rearview mirror, there was still an adrenaline rush on Christmas Eve that didn’t allow easy sleep.  The final hours of Christmas Eve and early hours of Christmas morning became bonus time for special projects, such alphabetizing a baseball card collection or beginning a Hardy Boys book saved for the occasion.

Eventually, adulthood intervened.  The fatigue of completing year-end work projects while simultaneously buying and wrapping gifts, sending cards, and preparing holiday meals overcame the adrenaline.  Sleep came easily and early on Christmas Eve.

But I still missed the bonus hours that once been mine in the anticipatory hours before Christmas Day.

So I decided to once again give myself a gift of found hours.

When I think over the urbanist reading I’ve down in recent years, the book that most frequently comes to mind is “Walkable City” by Jeff Speck.  Regular readers who note how often I cite Speck can hardly be surprised by this.  And the subtitle “How Downtown Can Save America, One Step at a Time” might as well be my personal mantra.

As I noted in my review, I find Speck a comfortable, friendly teacher, dispensing wisdom in simple, digestible, but still essential, packets.  No book learning experience can be accurately described as Socratic but “Walkable City” comes as close to that ideal as can be imagined.

And Speck is equally personable away from his writing table, as can be read in this interview from when the book was first published.  I love the playfulness of using “propinquity” and “frisson” in a single sentence.

I’ve often wished for the time to reread “Walkable City” but other urbanist tomes demanded my attention first, so I deferred my wish.  However, I conceived that rereading “Walkable City” would be a fine gift to myself for the found hours of a Christmas Eve.

So my goal became to finish my final Christmas chores, including hosting a Christmas Eve gathering and doing the post-party clean up, and then settling into a rereading of “Walkable City”, using future visions of Christmas Day gift giving and family dinner to keep me alert.

How’d it work?  Not well.  After more than six decades of life, fatigue can too easily overcome even the most motivated adrenaline.   After only 22 pages, sleep overcame me.  But they were a great 22 pages.

The relaxed week between today and New Years Eve now looms before me.  Perhaps Christmas Eve didn’t work out as well as I had hoped, but I can still give myself a holiday gift of reading.  I plan to finish up “Walkable City” before the week is out.

Whether for a first reading or a rereading, I encourage you to also partake of “Walkable City” this holiday season.  It might be the best gift you receive.  And your advocacy of the ideas espoused by Speck may be the best gift your city can receive.

From my first post-Christmas post as I gear up for the challenges of 2016, I’ll again venture around my neighborhood as I did in my search for missing middle housing, but this time I’ll be looking at the humble bench, the welcome relief it can provide for tired feet, and the chance offered for neighborhood conversation.

As always, your questions or comments will be appreciated.  Please comment below or email me.  And thanks for reading. - Dave Alden (davealden53@comcast.net)

Monday, March 24, 2014

Thoughtful Balancing Better than Rigid Rules

My last three posts might have projected a curmudgeonly air.  I didn’t feel curmudgeonly when writing them.  But when I read back over them, I realize that I may have come across as grumpy by challenging the civic value of some parks, by suggesting that the environmental elements of a road design might have been incorrectly valued more highly than walkability, and by arguing that historic preservation can sometimes go awry.

But upon looking deeper, there’s a connection between the posts that was decidedly not cranky.

Parks?  Love them, as long as they’re well-used and building a better community.

Environmental-sensitive roadway design?  Great idea, as long as we don’t put it on a pedestal above a greater civic good such as walkability.

Historic preservation?  Absolutely supportive.  It’s always painful to lose an older building, especially when it’s architecturally interesting or historically relevant.  But historic preservation must be within the context of building a better city.  If a building can’t be made to fit with a city that is evolving in a healthy direction, then perhaps it should be demolished, for the greater good.

So I’m not a curmudgeon.  It’s just that I believe in a higher good.  That higher good being a well-functioning, environmentally-sustainable, and financially-stable city.

In “Walkable City”, author Jeff Speck writes about how wide Main Street would become if we allowed every specialist to claim his or her optimal width.  Between two lanes of travel in each direction, left turn pockets, landscaped medians, wide bicycle lanes, diagonal parking, etc, our downtown streets would become wide enough to serve as runways.  The vastness of the street would inhibit walkability because of the daunting task of crossing the street and because of the exposed feeling of being on a sidewalk where the building across the street is more than 150 feet away.

Speck uses that example to argue that we can’t allow specialists to design our streets.  Instead, we should rely on generalists who understand the concern and desires of the specialists, but are capable of finding reasonable balances between the competing demands.  I think it’s one of the best points that Speck makes in his book.

I also feel that the point about specialists versus generalists can be extended to standards such as park requirements and historic preservation.  In the abstract, those requirements may seem absolute positives.  But the real world can often undermine what seems unassailable in the abstract, resulting in logical absurdities.  We need processes that allow us to find reasonable balances.

When I was younger, I was a fan of objective rules.  I thought that, if we’d only work a little harder, we could write objective rules that would cover every situation, making land development completely straight-forward and predictable.

I was wrong.  Reality has the unerring ability to find ambiguities, loopholes, and grey areas in any development standard that we write.  It was hubris to think that we could anticipate the myriad of possibilities that the real world could throw at us.

I’m not arguing that objective standards are never needed.  There are elements of land development where objective standards are an absolute necessity, such as water pressure, fire protection, and safe exits.

But there is also a need to admit that some development standards should be more subjective and to acknowledge that judgment, hopefully tempered by common sense, is needed to balance desirable but incompatible goals.

Those with a sense of land-use history may raise an objection at this point, noting that allowing more subjectivity into a hearing room would also allow more opportunity for decision-makers to be inappropriately influenced.  Those critics would be right.

I suspect that one of the reasons behind the rise of objective standards was to reduce the possibility of officials making decisions based on campaign contributions or other favors.  I also believe that objective standards have largely met that goal.

(For all of the complaints I hear about city hall being the lapdog of developers, there has probably been no time in history when that was less true than today.  There are certainly still pockets of undue influence, but the promulgation of transparent processes and objective rules have greatly reduced the opportunities.)

But excessive reliance on objective standards may result in worse decision-making than relying on the sometimes slanted subjective judgment of public officials.  The example I offered in my last post about the possibility of delaying a public housing project for reasons of historic preservation is only one example.

Compared to the rote application of objective standards, a little subjective balance can be a good thing, even if it comes with a risk of increased bribery or graft.

I understand that the fringes of the internet are populated by folks who will willfully misinterpret content so they can attack with contrived outrage.  So I’m sure that someone will read what I’ve written above and argue “Wow, this guy thinks that graft is a good thing.”

I’ve said nothing of the sort.  Instead, I’ve suggested that, in a headlong effort to eradicate bribery and graft, we’ve imposed rules that sometimes lead to deeply flawed land-use decisions.  Compared to the cost of those land-use mistakes, risking a little graft might be acceptable.  Although we should remain ever alert to malfeasance so it can be quickly rooted out.

Before closing, I should turn this conversation back toward urbanism.  Subjective balancing of land-use goals is more important to walkable urban development than it is to drivable suburban.  On a typical drivable suburban site, there’s room to move elements around to meet objective standards.  But a typical walkable urban site doesn’t have that flexibility.  And yet urban sites are more likely to have conflicts with objective standards such as historic preservation.

The trend over the past decades toward objective standards in place of subjective balancing is yet one more piece of evidence that our land-use processes were developed during a time when drivable suburban was the default land-use pattern.  It’s also another example of the subtle but effective systemic biases against urbanism.


As always, your questions or comments will be appreciated.  Please comment below or email me.  And thanks for reading. - Dave Alden (davealden53@comcast.net)

Wednesday, March 19, 2014

Northern California Tour: Freedom Park Road

Two weeks ago, I began recounting a recent daytrip I took through Northern California.  My goal was to look, however briefly, at destinations that I hoped would offer urbanist insights.  I began my day in Suisun City, a city center of well-conceived urban redevelopment and a personal favorite.  I continued with a stop in Woodland, checking on how the burgeoning big box district was affecting the attractive but languishing historical downtown.

Today, I’ll describe the next destination on my meandering route and the reason I conceived the daytrip, a recently reconstructed road in North Highlands, near Sacramento.

Sacramento County received an award from the local chapter of the American Planning Association for the redesign and reconstruction of Freedom Park Road within the former McClellan Air Force Base.  The grounds for the award are evident.  Wide and comfortable sidewalks.  Roundabouts in place of stop signs.  Stormwater runoff routed into vegetated swales.  Energy-efficient lighting.  A pavement mix design that included recycled tires.  All the elements of an environmentally-sensitive road design.

That is, all the elements of an environmentally-sensitive road design except the most important one.  Walkability.  Freedom Park Road has fine sidewalks, wide, without obstructions, and safely set back from the vehicle lanes.  But during the fifteen minutes I spent visiting the street, not one pedestrian came by.  None.

Nor is the reason surprising.  There are few destinations along the street.  Residential developments front on the street, an apartment complex to the south and small-lot single-family homes to the north.  But there’s virtually nowhere to go for anyone who lives in either.

Retail is usually the key destination.  At the east end of Freedom Park Road, where it terminates at an arterial, there are strip malls on both corners, but they‘re half-empty and moribund.

Otherwise, there’s a park that includes casual play and organized sports areas.  But casual play parks sometimes struggle to attract users and it’s likely the many of organized sports participants arrive by car from points of origin far beyond Freedom Park Road.

There’s also an aerospace museum that I’ve visited and enjoyed.  But realistically, how many times can people visit the same museum?  Perhaps twice a year?

Overall, it’s not surprising that the only folks I saw along Freedom Park Road, other than the drivers of
passing cars, were a handful of teenagers sitting at the entry to the apartments, looking at the world through bored, half-closed eyes.

If we use Jeff Speck’s “Walkable City” for its walkability punchlist, the shortfalls are further highlighted.  Safety?  Yes.  Comfort?  So it appeared to me.  Interest?  Not much.  Most of the uses are not visually appealing, set far back from the street, or both.  Usefulness?  Nope, barring the occasional purchase that can be made at the struggling strip malls or the infrequent desire to play on a swing, there’s not much useful on Freedom Park Road.  With all four points needed to for a street to be walkable, Freedom Park Road falls well short.

I understand why the APA gave an award for the road reconstruction.  I’m sure that design touched on many of the hot buttons in environmental design.  But the fact remains that virtually every street in downtown Sacramento, by facilitating walkability, provides more environmental benefit than Freedom Park Road.

Don’t misunderstand my point.  I’m not saying that vegetated swales and energy-efficient lights are bad road elements.  Instead, I agree that they are very good road elements.  But the ultimate good road element, the essential road element, is walkable urbanism and if we aren’t encouraging urbanism, we’re only chipping at the fringe of the environmental challenge.

In his book “Hot, Flat, and Crowded”, New York Times journalist Thomas Friedman argues that many Americans, faced with the environmental challenges of the 21st century, are going only as far as a “green party”.  Rather than making fundamental changes in their lifestyles, they’re setting out the recycling can, replacing incandescent bulbs with CFLs, throwing a handful of confetti, and carrying on with life as they’ve always known it. 

He makes a good point.  All of us, me included, can and should do more to face the challenges of our time.  And passing out an award for a road that doesn’t address walkability, the keystone of environmental sustainability, is a good example of a premature and unjustified green party.


As always, your questions or comments will be appreciated.  Please comment below or email me.  And thanks for reading. - Dave Alden (davealden53@comcast.net)